Skip to content
  • HOME
  • SHOP Candy & Gifts
    • Apparel
      • Jewelry & Accessories
      • Pura Vida
      • SillyBandz
      • T-shirts & Sweatshirts
      • Zox
    • Candy
      • Bulk Jelly Belly
      • Bulk Saltwater Taffy
      • Chocolate
      • Cotton Candy
      • Gummy Candy
      • Jelly Belly Novelty
      • Jelly Belly Harry Potter
      • M&M's Colorworks
      • Novelty
      • Soda
    • Gifts
      • Cat Lovers
      • Gifts Under $20
      • Golden Lovers
      • Warmies
    • Kawaii
    • Slime, Putty, Dough
    • Stickers
    • Toys & Games
      • Calico Critters
      • Fidgets
      • Games
      • Folkmanis Puppets
      • Nee Doh
      • Perfect Petzzz
      • Plush
      • Schleich
      • Other Fun Stuff
  • Shop Pets
    • Cat
    • Dog
      • Bandanas
      • Toys
      • Treats
  • Account
Sully Loves Sugar
Cart
  • HOME
  • SHOP Candy & Gifts
    • Apparel
      • Jewelry & Accessories
      • Pura Vida
      • SillyBandz
      • T-shirts & Sweatshirts
      • Zox
    • Candy
      • Bulk Jelly Belly
      • Bulk Saltwater Taffy
      • Chocolate
      • Cotton Candy
      • Gummy Candy
      • Jelly Belly Novelty
      • Jelly Belly Harry Potter
      • M&M's Colorworks
      • Novelty
      • Soda
    • Gifts
      • Cat Lovers
      • Gifts Under $20
      • Golden Lovers
      • Warmies
    • Kawaii
    • Slime, Putty, Dough
    • Stickers
    • Toys & Games
      • Calico Critters
      • Fidgets
      • Games
      • Folkmanis Puppets
      • Nee Doh
      • Perfect Petzzz
      • Plush
      • Schleich
      • Other Fun Stuff
  • Shop Pets
    • Cat
    • Dog
      • Bandanas
      • Toys
      • Treats
Account
Item added to cart. View cart and check out.
Candy! Toys! Gifts!

Cat Lovers

Cat Warmies
Cat Warmies
Sold Out
View
Cat Junior Warmies
Cat Junior Warmies
Regular price $13.99
View
Perfect Petzzz Calico Kitten Toys
Perfect Petzzz Calico Kitten
Sold Out
View
Laying Down Gray Cat Warmies Plush
Laying Down Gray Cat Warmies
Regular price $29.99
View
Calico Cat Warmies
Calico Cat Warmies
Regular price $29.99
View
Jinx The Black Cat Plush
Jinx the Black Cat
Sold Out
View
Cleo The Siamese Cat Plush
Cleo the Siamese Cat
Sold Out
View
Perfect Petzzz B&W Shorthair Kitten Toys
Perfect Petzzz B&W Shorthair Kitten
Sold Out
View
Perfect Petzzz Orange Tabby Kitten Toys
Perfect Petzzz Orange Tabby Kitten
Sold Out
View
Socks The Gray Cat Plush
Socks the Gray Cat
Sold Out
View
Kawaii Cat Plush Toys
Kawaii Cat Plush Toys
Sold Out
View
Simulation Siamese Cat Plush Toy
Siamese Cat Plush
Sold Out
View
Terrence The Sleepy Tiger Stuffed Animal Plush
Terrence The Sleepy Tiger Stuffed Animal Plush
Sold Out
View
Toysmith Catstronaut Slow-Rise Squishy Ball Toys
Toysmith Catstronaut Slow-Rise Squishy Ball
Sold Out
View
Domino The Black & White Cat Plush
Domino the Black & White Cat
Regular price $21.99
View
Amy the American Shorthair Cat Stuffed Animal Plush
Amy the American Shorthair Cat Stuffed Animal Plush
Sold Out
View
Kawaii Cat Plush Toys
Kawaii Cat Plush
Regular price $29.99
View
Soft Cat Plush Pillow
Soft Cat Plush Pillow
Regular price $29.99
View
Cat Face Shark Plush Toy
Cat Face Shark Plush Toy
Regular price $44.99
View
Soft Cat Plush Pillow
Soft Cat Plush Pillow
Regular price $19.99
View
1 2 3 →

Info

  • About Us
  • Giving Back
  • Returns
  • Privacy Policy
  • TikTok Shenanigans

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Media

  • Marshfield Mail
  • SBJ
© 2023, Sully Loves Sugar. Powered by Shopify
  • american express
  • apple pay
  • diners club
  • discover
  • google pay
  • master
  • paypal
  • shopify pay
  • visa